Home » Technology » IEEE 1901 and the HomePlug Alliance

IEEE P1901 and the HomePlug Alliance

Consumers win with the publication and Sponsor Ballot Approval of the IEEE 1901 global powerline standard

Since the inception of the IEEE P1901 workgroup in 2005 (see timeline below), industry leaders from around the world have worked tirelessly to drive the development of a global high-speed powerline communication (PLC) standard. This is the first such standard coming from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – the same organization that created standards for 802.3 Ethernet and 802.11 Wireless technologies.1 

The results of the first Sponsor Ballot, held in April 2010, showed 81% voted in favor of the 1901 standard -- an unprecedented show of industry support for a technology of such complexity.  

New Technologies Conquer Old Problems

The idea of pressing power lines into performing double-duty (as both a provider of electric current and a carrier of communications signaling) has been attempted with varying success for over one hundred years. Early PLC systems were used for remote meter reading, and to monitor voltages in telegraph systems.

The primary issue has been to overcome the challenging environment on power lines. Scientific American said that using power lines for data communication is “like trying to transcribe the exact score of a symphony—as it is played over the loudspeakers at a packed football stadium, on a windy night, during the final minutes of a tied Super Bowl game, while wearing earmuffs.” 2  Hair dryers, dimmers, vacuums, and other appliances cause unpredictable noise, and due to the number of switches on the network, its size and characteristics can change at a moment’s notice.

What makes it all work is a complex amalgam of signal processing technologies and new modulation techniques that exceeds anything previously attempted. Additionally, advances in semiconductor geometries helps reduce the cost of implementing products.

Setting the Goals for a Robust PLC Technology

The P1901 workgroup set a goal: to define a MAC/PHY standard for PLC devices delivering over 100Mbps. The standard would apply to all classes of devices, such as those used in LANs, Smart Energy, transportation platforms (vehicles), and in data distribution applications. Other important goals included a balanced and efficient use of the PLC channel, mechanisms for coexistence and interoperability, security and privacy, and ensuring the delivery of desired bandwidth and quality of service.3  

In December 2008, the P1901 workgroup voted to include OFDM-based PHY options based on both FFT and Wavelet PHYs. This made 1901 standard interoperable with the world’s market-leading PLC technologies, and helped ensure it reflects the best available technology, serving the growing needs of the industry as a whole.

Developing the IEEE 1901 Global Standard 

By nature, the powerline medium is open, and shared by multiple devices. By being independent and openly defined, the IEEE 1901 standard avoids problems by ensuring that PLC devices offer the best service possible, even when the medium is serving multiple applications. Full implementations of 1901 provide interoperability among PLC devices and other networking protocols (such as seamless interconnection via 802.1), while partial implementations ensure fair coexistence. Also, the standard complies with EMC limits set by national regulators to ensure coexistence with wireless and telecom systems.

The IEEE Effect –
Broad Industry Support & Swift Market Growth

Recently, the IEEE 1901 Draft Standard was deemed sufficiently mature for general release, and it is available now through the IEEE online store.

Historically, when the IEEE P1901 working group makes standards available to implementers and manufacturers, an increasing number of new players begin to enter the market. Similar to the growth that wireless technologies experienced once the IEEE delivered the 802.11 standards, many expect the publication of the 1901 standard to boost the adoption rate of PLC technology, unite the industry, and provide very strong benefits to the consumer.

Multiple semiconductor vendors have already announced plans to deliver integrated circuits (ICs) based on the IEEE 1901 standard. Additionally, many current powerline products are expected to be fully interoperable with the 1901 standard, ensuring a seamless roadmap for over 40 million existing users of the technology.

The HomePlug Alliance is enhancing the HomePlug AV Certification Program for products based on the IEEE P1901 standard. This program ensures that reliable interoperable products will be available from multiple suppliers.

The many benefits of easy-to-use, secure, and reliable PLC technology are about to be realized by more people than ever before as the technology is incorporated into products in consumer electronics, smart grid, and other growing markets.


P1901 Milestones

  • April 9, 2010: The initial Sponsor Ballot in the IEEE P1901 working group shows broad industry support with 81% voting in favor. Approval is targeted for September. Click these links for the press release  and blog
  • April 2010:  The IEEE-SA appoints the HomePlug Powerline Alliance and the HD-PLC Alliance to jointly certify the IEEE 1901 Inter-System Protocol (ISP) which allows coexistence between PLC technologies
  • February 2010: IEEE 1901 Standard Moves Into Sponsor Balloting Stage - Key Smart Grid standard reaches final balloting step
  • January 2010: IEEE 1901 Draft Standard is published by the IEEE
  • December 2009: All comments are resolved
  • July 2009: The first Draft Standard is created and delivered for comment
  • February 2009: Four Technical Subgroups begin work on a unified document of the standard
  • December 2008: All proposals are confirmed
  • September 2008: Second round of confirmation voting and a voluntary proposal merger yields a single proposal
  • July 2008: First round of confirmation voting
  • October 2007: First elimination vote, and by March, only one proposal remains in each cluster
  • September 2007: Two proposals per cluster remain after voluntary mergers
  • June 2007: 12 proposals received
  • February 2007: 400 requirements split into three clusters
  • September 2006: Channel and noise models defined
  • January 2006: Use cases defined
  • June 2005: PAR approved

 

  1. See the IEEE's website at http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/1901

  2. From "The Network in Every Room" by W. Wayt Gibbs, Scientific American, Feb 2002. 

  3. Details on the IEEE 1901 technology are described in "Recent Developments in the Standardization of Powerline Communications within the IEEE" in IEEE Communications Magazine, July 2008. To inquire about reprints, visit http://ww2.comsoc.org/contact.